Assertion & Reason

Study Materials › Reasoning › Assertion & Reason

You are given two statements — an Assertion (A) and a Reason (R) — and must decide whether each is true and whether R actually explains A. The last part is where most marks are lost: two perfectly true statements about the same topic do not necessarily stand in an explanatory relationship.

The Standard Options

(1) A is true, R is true, and R is the correct explanation of A.

(2) A is true, R is true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.

(3) A is true but R is false.

(4) A is false but R is true.

Work in Three Steps, in This Order

1. Is A true on its own? If false, you are down to option (4) immediately.

2. Is R true on its own? If false, the answer is (3).

3. Only if both are true: does R answer the question "why is A the case?"

Never judge step 3 first. Deciding the relationship before establishing that both statements are individually true is the most common way this question type is failed — and options (3) and (4) exist precisely to catch it.

Worked Examples from Real Papers

TS Police SI 2022 — Q70

Assertion (A): Antibiotics do not treat the Corona infection.
Reason (R): Corona is a virus, not a bacteria.

A is true — antibiotics are ineffective against COVID-19.
R is true — SARS-CoV-2 is a virus.
Does R explain A? Yes, and directly: antibiotics work by attacking bacterial structures and processes, which viruses do not have. R gives precisely the reason A holds.
Answer: A is true, R is true, and R is the correct explanation of A.

TS Police SI 2022 — Q122

Assertion (A): Balban could not raise the numerical strength of the army to the level which it reached later at the time of Allauddin Khilji.
Reason (R): Balban insisted upon high birth as an essential qualification for appointment to higher civil and military posts.

A is true — Alauddin Khilji's army was substantially larger than Balban's.
R is true — Balban's insistence on noble birth for high office is well documented.
Does R explain A? Yes. Restricting appointments to men of high birth shrinks the pool available for recruitment, which limits how large the force can grow.
Answer: A is true, R is true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
Note: assertion-reason questions frequently carry subject content — here medieval history rather than logic. The three-step method still applies, but you need the underlying fact to judge steps 1 and 2.

TS Police SI 2022 — Q74

Assertion (A): Nowadays knee pain is a common complaint. Knee replacement is a boon for such sufferers.
Reason (R): Necessity is the mother of invention.

A is true — knee pain is widespread and replacement surgery benefits those affected.
R is true as a general principle.
Does R explain A? This is the interesting part. The proverb might explain why the procedure was developed, but A claims something narrower — that the procedure is a boon to sufferers. A general aphorism about invention does not establish that a specific treatment is effective.
Answer: A is true, R is true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
The lesson: a proverb or broad generalisation offered as a Reason is rarely the correct explanation of a specific Assertion. When R is much wider in scope than A, suspect option (2).

Watch the scope of R. If the Reason is a general truth and the Assertion is a specific claim, R usually fails the explanation test. If R names the actual mechanism behind A — as in the antibiotics example — it usually passes.

Also see: Statement & Arguments · Assumptions & Conclusions · Data Sufficiency